(regan, 83, paragraphs 2-4)
Regan's approach to animals rights comes from the idea of contractarianism. Essentially he says, morality consists of a set of rules that individuals voluntarily agree to abide by. People who understand and accept the terms of the contract are covered directly and have rights that are created and subsequently protected by the contract. This contract extends to young children, although they are not able to sign by proxy they are protected. THe issue is the taken one step further and applied to animals.
Some animals have sentimental value within a family and in some cases people consider their pets to part of their family. THerefore the rules that extend to children also can be extended to animals such as family pets. Also animals that are considered to be endangered fall under this category, people spend their life and hold jobs that are geared toward preserving and protecting various species that are in danger of going extinct. The problem comes from the fact that the animals that we eat on a daily basis are completely disregarded. We don't have any connection to them and therefore once again the disconnect that humans have enters in to play. A farm animal essentially means nothing to us and is just a product and a means to an end.
Regan says that contractarianism isn't an appropriate justification for the moral status of humans at the end of the day. THerefore, if it isn't an adequate approach to justify the equality and rights of humans, it cannot appropriately be applied to animals. Regan goes once step further an examines Rawl's version of this theory...Contractarianism does not fully work because within the theory there are contradictions. By virtue of what the system and concept is, we realistically do not have direct duties to younger children. Therefore we definitely don't have a duty toward animals. However, we would never do something that would be viewed as wrong in terms of the treatment of children but yet we have no problem doing something that could be considered wrong in the treatment of animals. Therefore, you can't fully say and justify that killing animals and eating them is okay.
response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/prompt-05-reading-for-the-conversation/
Saturday, January 14, 2012
Friday, January 13, 2012
Prompt 4
(Singer, 76, second full paragraph)
In discussing animal liberation, Singer makes mention of many philosophers and others who have argued about the humanity of using animals for experiments. As humans, we don't think about doing tests on human subjects because it would be cruel and inhumane. Additionally, it isnt allowed and there are numerous laws against testing on humans. The only exception to the rule would be drug trials but that is a separate issue and the argument for or against that can take on many identities. Singers mentions that we would never attempt to experiment on a human infant because we consider them to be one of us, therefore our willingness and ease with which we experiment on animals is discrimination. It's because there is a disconnect and people do not view it in the same light. This is speciesism in action. Unless the practice of animal experimentation goes away speciesism will continue to exist. Taking this one step further, killing animals is yet another display of specisism. This ties into the response that i wrote about last night to many people's prompts. Its hard to argue that eating animals is moral in any way but it is also hard to say that it is immoral. With that said the way the animals are put into small spaces and literally piled on top of each other prior to being slaughtered is inhumane. Reading Singer's article really brought my attention to how much speciesism exists. I was aware of what it was but i never thought that just the act of eating an animal is an example of it. And honestly it really is, it is a pure form of discrimination but just not in the typical way that we view discrimination. Because typically in the human race we view discrimination as an act done unto others (humans) rather than an animal.
response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-04prompt-04-introduction-to-animal-rights-and-liberation/
In discussing animal liberation, Singer makes mention of many philosophers and others who have argued about the humanity of using animals for experiments. As humans, we don't think about doing tests on human subjects because it would be cruel and inhumane. Additionally, it isnt allowed and there are numerous laws against testing on humans. The only exception to the rule would be drug trials but that is a separate issue and the argument for or against that can take on many identities. Singers mentions that we would never attempt to experiment on a human infant because we consider them to be one of us, therefore our willingness and ease with which we experiment on animals is discrimination. It's because there is a disconnect and people do not view it in the same light. This is speciesism in action. Unless the practice of animal experimentation goes away speciesism will continue to exist. Taking this one step further, killing animals is yet another display of specisism. This ties into the response that i wrote about last night to many people's prompts. Its hard to argue that eating animals is moral in any way but it is also hard to say that it is immoral. With that said the way the animals are put into small spaces and literally piled on top of each other prior to being slaughtered is inhumane. Reading Singer's article really brought my attention to how much speciesism exists. I was aware of what it was but i never thought that just the act of eating an animal is an example of it. And honestly it really is, it is a pure form of discrimination but just not in the typical way that we view discrimination. Because typically in the human race we view discrimination as an act done unto others (humans) rather than an animal.
response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-04prompt-04-introduction-to-animal-rights-and-liberation/
Thursday, January 12, 2012
Prompt 3
In reading through various blogs, I found Car Emissions post the most interesting. I could definitely tell that he was speaking from a true place and provided the example about his Cockatoo to back up his position. His argument was strong and made me think about things in another way.
I had never necessarily reasoned that keeping animals in a zoo keeps them from being in danger of becoming extinct. Upon further thinking, I began to realize that maybe I had thought of that but then I immediately rode it off. Animals such as polar bears of koala bears feed into the argument of taking animals out of their natural habitat and putting them in to zoos for the greater good of the species. Therefore in some cases I believe that having animals in zoos most definitely serves a purpose.
Other animals however do not need to be in a zoo. Allowing an animal to live in its natural habit is more human than taking it and placing it elsewhere. Animals are part of the ecosystem of the food chain and when nature is interfered with my man (therefore in an unnatural manner) it throws off the balance. Nature should be allowed to exist and be carried out as it is intended, through natural selection and survival of the fittest. Interference by man complicates things and throws off the balance and the natural ways of nature.
Response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-03prompt-03-relationship-of-ethics-and-environmental-ethics/
Response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-03prompt-03-relationship-of-ethics-and-environmental-ethics/
Prompt 2
I feel as if morals that people hold are extremely inconsistent. Additionally, morals are rather subjective and vary from culture to culture. The best example of this can come from the example about the cat. If we twist it around a little bit and substitute a dog for a cat, one may argue that it is morally wrong and repugnant to eat a dog. This however occurs in other countries such as China. As citizens of the United States we view this to be relatively disgusting. Just because it is viewed as disgusting doesn't mean it isn't moral but chances are most people take it one step further and do believe that it is morally wrong. Myself is included in that.
So back to the car scenario, although I found it to be disgusting and morally wrong, I can also see the opposing side of such a scenario. How can one condemn this situation when we eat various animals all the time (i.e - chicken, turkey, duck, etc). It is a bit contradictory on our part to say that eating an animal such as a cat would be immoral. We most likely deem it to be immoral because it is not something that we are used to and in our culture and country it is not common practice.
The third scenario dealing with incest was probably the most unsettling to me. Realistically, if you think about it in context of the exact scenario presented: no one was actually harmed or put in harms way. Once I got passed that however (even though on the quiz I did answer that people were harmed. I soon rethought that post-quiz) I realized that much of my problem with the scenario came from the fact that i just thought it was straight up disgusting. If the scenario was changed fully and the woman was able to get pregnant, then that would add a whole other layer to the situation. Then I could sit here and 100% say that people would end up being harmed as a result of the situation.
This quiz proved to be that at times (if not a large majority of times) I am inconsistent with my opinions and views. This inconsistency is driven by the fact that I allow my opinion (level of disgust) to influence and get in the way of my overall moral opinion on various issues. With that said, being as I feel that i don't necessarily think in the most philosophical of manners; prior to this writing prompt i never thought i was being inconsistent. I had also worked under the assumption that how various situations caused one to feel was directly correlated with ones own set of moral beliefs and codes.
Response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-02prompt-02-what-is-ethics-contd/
So back to the car scenario, although I found it to be disgusting and morally wrong, I can also see the opposing side of such a scenario. How can one condemn this situation when we eat various animals all the time (i.e - chicken, turkey, duck, etc). It is a bit contradictory on our part to say that eating an animal such as a cat would be immoral. We most likely deem it to be immoral because it is not something that we are used to and in our culture and country it is not common practice.
The third scenario dealing with incest was probably the most unsettling to me. Realistically, if you think about it in context of the exact scenario presented: no one was actually harmed or put in harms way. Once I got passed that however (even though on the quiz I did answer that people were harmed. I soon rethought that post-quiz) I realized that much of my problem with the scenario came from the fact that i just thought it was straight up disgusting. If the scenario was changed fully and the woman was able to get pregnant, then that would add a whole other layer to the situation. Then I could sit here and 100% say that people would end up being harmed as a result of the situation.
This quiz proved to be that at times (if not a large majority of times) I am inconsistent with my opinions and views. This inconsistency is driven by the fact that I allow my opinion (level of disgust) to influence and get in the way of my overall moral opinion on various issues. With that said, being as I feel that i don't necessarily think in the most philosophical of manners; prior to this writing prompt i never thought i was being inconsistent. I had also worked under the assumption that how various situations caused one to feel was directly correlated with ones own set of moral beliefs and codes.
Response to: http://parenethical.com/phil149win12/lecture-02prompt-02-what-is-ethics-contd/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)